Most golfers assume a longer putter exists solely to accommodate height. In reality, these clubs rely on a pendulum stroke that stabilizes the entire arm assembly. Choosing the Best Broomstick Putters involves balancing personal comfort with your specific alignment preferences.
You want a club that feels like an extension of your body rather than a heavy accessory. Let's examine the options that prioritize consistent contact and accuracy on the green.
Key Takeaways
- Prioritize a length that allows your eyes to sit directly over the ball when your arms hang in a relaxed, tension-free position.
- Select a grip profile that feels comfortable in your hands, as larger grips often help minimize unwanted wrist movement during the stroke.
- Consider the head weight of the putter, because a heavier head often provides better stability for the longer shaft lengths typical of broomstick models.
- Analyze the face milling pattern, since aggressive patterns can influence roll speed and ball direction upon initial impact.
- Ensure the head design matches your natural stroke path, whether you tend to putt with a straight back-and-through motion or a slight arc.
| The Anchor Benchmark | Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 Broom Putter | Extremely stable head shape | Consistent pendulum stroke | High forgiveness | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Perfect Length Alternative | Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 Broom Putter 46" | Ideal for shorter players | Excellent alignment features | Consistent face technology | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Geometric Precision Master |  |
Odyssey Square To Square Putter | Promotes square impact | Minimizes face rotation | Innovative stroke geometry | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| High MOI King |  |
TaylorMade Spider X Broom Putter | Massive forgiveness levels | Stable perimeter weighting | Modern aesthetic appeal | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Essential Grip Upgrade |  |
Winn Excel Two-Piece Putter Grip | Superior tackiness | Two-piece customization | Comfortable hand feel | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Tour Proven Feel |  |
Odyssey S2S Tri Hot Putter | Exceptional impact feedback | Classic, refined look | Responsive face feel | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Compact Stroke Specialist | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8 | Compact head design | Clean address profile | Consistent face technology | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Stability Focused Mallet |  |
TaylorMade Spider ZT Putter | Superior glare reduction | Exceptional stability | Perfect address balance | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Unique Performance Piece |  |
Zeety Hockey Style CNC Putter | Striking visual design | Precision milled face | Unique shaft aesthetic | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Traditionalist Blade Choice | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 | Timeless blade design | Crisp impact feel | High distance accuracy | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 Broom Putter
This 48-inch model is arguably the most popular choice for golfers transitioning to the broomstick style. The #11 head shape provides a high degree of stability and forgiveness on off-center hits, which is exactly what you need when you are learning a new, longer stroke.
Because of the added length, the putter generates a very consistent pendulum motion. It is a fantastic option if you want a reliable, proven head design that prioritizes ball roll above all else. Just keep in mind that the longer shaft requires a bit of practice to adjust your stance to the correct height.
- Manufacturer:Cleveland Golf
- Length:48 inches
- Head Style:#11 Mallet
- Additional Feature:Speed optimized face technology
- Additional Feature:Soft feel impact zone
- Additional Feature:Balanced weight distribution
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 Broom Putter 46"
Sometimes 48 inches is just a bit too long for your specific setup. This 46-inch version offers the exact same high-performance head as its taller sibling but caters to golfers who prefer to stand slightly closer to the ball.
The #11 design is excellent for alignment assistance, featuring clear sightlines that help you aim true. It is a solid choice if you feel the 48-inch model forces you into an uncomfortable posture. It remains a very steady performer in the short game.
- Manufacturer:Cleveland Golf
- Length:46 inches
- Head Style:#11 Mallet
- Additional Feature:Optimized face milling
- Additional Feature:Consistent roll pattern
- Additional Feature:Forgiving mallet design
-
Odyssey Square To Square Putter
Odyssey focuses on the geometry of your stroke here by promoting a square face angle throughout the entire swing arc. The design is intended to minimize the rotation of the putter face, which is a common cause of missed putts for those who struggle with hand manipulation.
It is built for players who want a technological advantage in keeping the putter head on line. You might find the unique shape takes a few rounds to get used to visually, but the mechanical benefits are clear.
- Manufacturer:Odyssey Golf
- Head Style:Mallet
- Additional Feature:High inertia design
- Additional Feature:Alignment-focused head shape
- Additional Feature:Consistent ball contact
-
TaylorMade Spider X Broom Putter
The Spider X is famous for its high MOI, or Moment of Inertia, which basically means it resists twisting when you do not hit the center of the face. For a broomstick setup, this provides a rock-solid feel that gives you immense confidence during long lag putts.
The weighting system is pushed to the perimeter, creating a very stable platform. This is a top-tier selection if you want a modern, high-tech look that prioritizes keeping the head steady through the zone.
- Manufacturer:TaylorMade Golf
- Head Style:Spider Mallet
- Additional Feature:High MOI construction
- Additional Feature:Advanced alignment system
- Additional Feature:Smooth roll face insert
-
Winn Excel Two-Piece Putter Grip
While technically an accessory, this grip is the vital component of any custom broomstick build. Since broomstick putters require a unique hand position, the two-piece design allows you to customize the spacing between your hands for optimal control.
Winn is known for their tacky, comfortable material that stays soft even in humid conditions. It is perfect if you are building your own putter or looking to replace a worn grip on an existing long stick.
- Manufacturer:Winn
- Grip Type:Two-piece long grip
- Additional Feature:Vibration dampening material
- Additional Feature:Weather resistant finish
- Additional Feature:Easy installation design
-
Odyssey S2S Tri Hot Putter
The Tri Hot series is a favorite among professionals for its refined feel and touch. When adapted for a broomstick stroke, you get that same premium feedback combined with the stability of a long-putter setup.
It provides a more traditional aesthetic compared to some of the bulkier modern mallets. If you prefer a putter that feels responsive and offers great distance control, this is a very strong contender.
- Manufacturer:Odyssey Golf
- Head Style:Blade/Mallet hybrid
- Additional Feature:Tour-inspired weighting
- Additional Feature:Precision milled face
- Additional Feature:Balanced shaft alignment
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8
Model 8 is a slightly different take from Cleveland that provides a more compact appearance at address. It is ideal for players who find large mallet heads distracting or prefer the visual simplicity of a blade-style putter.
Despite the slimmer profile, it still carries the speed-optimized technology found in the wider models. It performs best for those who already have a decent grasp of their stroke path and want a cleaner look.
- Manufacturer:Cleveland Golf
- Model:8
- Head Style:Blade
- Additional Feature:Optimized milling pattern
- Additional Feature:Soft impact zone
- Additional Feature:Balanced weight profile
-
TaylorMade Spider ZT Putter
The Spider ZT focuses heavily on alignment and stability through a reinforced head structure. It is designed to sit perfectly flat, which is essential when you are holding a long putter and trying to maintain a consistent eye line.
The finish is designed to reduce glare, which is a thoughtful touch for those bright afternoons on the green. You will appreciate how easy it is to keep the putter head square through the backswing and follow-through.
- Manufacturer:TaylorMade Golf
- Head Style:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Reinforced head structure
- Additional Feature:Alignment-focused finish
- Additional Feature:Consistent roll characteristics
-
Zeety Hockey Style CNC Putter
If you want something that stands out in the bag, this CNC-milled putter features a distinctive aesthetic that mimics the shape of a hockey stick. Beyond the looks, the precision milling on the face ensures a consistent ball launch every time.
It is a great conversation starter that actually performs well on the green. The wood-grain shaft adds a touch of class to a very unconventional design.
- Manufacturer:ZEETY
- Head Style:Hockey style
- Material:Milled steel
- Additional Feature:Bronze finish
- Additional Feature:Happy letter grip
- Additional Feature:High precision face
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1
Model 1 is the quintessential blade-style putter for those who refuse to use a mallet. It offers a classic look that many golfers find more intuitive, especially when you are standing tall with a broomstick-style shaft.
The feel is crisp and predictable, allowing you to judge distance with high accuracy. It is a great choice if you prefer to feel the putter head move through the stroke rather than relying on a heavy mallet to do the work for you.
- Manufacturer:Cleveland Golf
- Model:1
- Head Style:Blade
- Additional Feature:Optimized milling face
- Additional Feature:Consistent ball roll
- Additional Feature:Balanced weight distribution
Frequently Asked Questions
Why would I choose a broomstick putter over a standard putter?
If you struggle with the yips or have inconsistent speed control, a broomstick putter can provide much-needed stability. By using your lead arm as a fulcrum, you remove the small, twitchy muscles in your wrists from the equation. It is like replacing a shaky hand with a locked mechanical arm.
Are broomstick putters still legal for competitive play?
Yes, they are perfectly legal, provided you do not anchor the club against your body. You must keep the grip end separated from your chest or chin throughout the stroke. As long as you maintain a small gap between your body and the club, you are compliant with the rules.
Do I need a different putting stroke for this style?
You should focus on a shoulders-only motion rather than using your hands or wrists. Think of your arms as a rigid triangle that moves in sync with your upper body. It takes some time to adjust, but your stroke path will become much more repeatable once you stop trying to steer the ball.
Can I adjust the length of a broomstick putter myself?
You can technically cut down a steel shaft, but doing so will significantly alter the swing weight of the putter. If you shorten the shaft, the head will feel much lighter and you may lose that stable pendulum effect. It is almost always better to order the correct length from the manufacturer.
How do I transport a putter that is nearly five feet long?
These clubs rarely fit into a standard golf bag side pocket, so you might need a larger tour bag. Some players choose to carry the putter separately or use a headcover with a strap to secure it to the outside of their bag. Make sure your vehicle trunk has enough room to lay it down flat without putting stress on the shaft.
